1958 Boys Reserve Football
Season:
| Sat, Sep 13 | Home vs St. Xavier | W 8-6 | 1-0 / Elder scores on an 80yard pass play from Steve Tensi to Jim Hassett |
| Sat, Sep 20 | Away vs Roger Bacon | W 24-14 | 2-0 / Terry Rogers scored twice. Bushman and Elsaesser were also outstanding in this game |
| Sat, Sep 27 | Home vs Purcell | W 22-8 | 3-0 / A 70 yard pass play from Bushman to Hassett was the games highlight |
| Sat, Oct 04 | Home vs St. Rita's | W 20-8 | 4-0 / Mickey Lynch, Larry Cross and Jim Hassett al scored for the Panthers |
| Sat, Oct 11 | Away vs St. Xavier | T 8-8 | 4-0-1 / A Tensi to Hassett pass was the score for Elder in a rugged defensive struggle |
| Sat, Oct 18 | Away vs Western Hills | W 28-20 | 5-0-1 / "Old Faithful" Harry Elsaesser scored twice and Hassett and Lynch each once in the route |
| Sat, Oct 25 | Home vs Roger Bacon | L 12-20 | 5-1-1 / First Night Game with 1,200 in attendance |
| Sat, Nov 01 | Home vs Hamilton | W 26-12 | 6-1-1 / Larry Cross scored once as did Bushman and Rogers |
| Sat, Nov 08 | Away vs Purcell | W 14-6 | 7-1-1 / Another night game for the Reserves saw the Panthers beat the highly ranked Cavaliers |
| Sat, Nov 15 | Away vs Hamilton | W 22-6 | 8-1-1 / Hassett, Bushman and Rogers all scored once to make the ride back to Elder enjoyable. |
| Sat, Nov 22 | Home vs Hughes | W 22-14 | 9-1-1 / Elder defeated the public high champions after a first half in which the trailed 14-0. In the closing moments of the game, a Bushman to Rogers pass was the game winner for the Panthers! |